Hay for Horses in New York
Clean grass hay like timothy and orchard grass, with alfalfa when they need more. Compare local New York listings.
Horses Hay for Sale Near You
Horse Hay – Delivered to NY/NYC
Horse Hay
Contact for price · Old Bridge, NJ, NY
Second Cutting Alfalfa Hay — Square Bales
Alfalfa · Second Cutting
$9 / bale · Salem, NY
Hay for Sale
Grass Hay
Contact for price · North Salem, NY
First Cutting Timothy Grass Hay — Square Bales
Timothy / Grass Mix · First Cutting
$6 / bale · Salem, NY
Organic 2nd Cut Alfalfa – Large Rounds
Alfalfa (organic) · Second Cutting
$50 / bale · Penn Yan, NY
1st Cutting Organic Timothy
Timothy Grass (organic) · First Cutting
$7 / bale · Goshen, NY
Low Sugar/Starch Hay
Low-sugar Grass Hay
Contact for price · Hobart, NY
Full Hay Line – Horse & Livestock
Grass Hay
Contact for price · Salisbury Mills, NY
Organic 1st Cut Large Squares (3x3x7)
Mixed Grass · First Cutting
$60 / bale · Berkshire, NY
Cattle-Quality 1st Cut – Small Squares
Grass Mix · First Cutting
$3.3 / bale · Prattsburgh, NY
1st Cutting Timothy Grass – Small Squares
Timothy Grass · First Cutting
$7 / bale · Goshen, NY
Organic 1st Cut Round Bales (4×5)
Mixed Grass · First Cutting
$35 / bale · Berkshire, NY
New listings are added regularly. Browse all NY hay or post a Hay Wanted request.
What's the Best Hay for Horses?
Most horses do best on clean, dust-free grass hay — timothy or orchard grass — with alfalfa added only when a horse needs extra protein or calories.
Read the full Horses hay guideShop Hay for Other Animals
Goats · Cattle · Sheep · Rabbits · Guinea Pigs · Donkeys · Miniature Horses · Alpacas & Llamas · Chickens