Log in

Timothy Hay for Sale in New York

Timothy is a grass hay prized for horses — higher in fiber, lower in protein and calcium, and easy to feed daily. New York’s climate grows excellent timothy. Browse timothy hay for sale from NY farms below, compare cutting and price, and contact sellers directly.

Available Timothy Hay Listings

chicken foraging hay best hay for chickens

Timothy/Orchard Horse Hay – Small Squares

Timothy/Orchard Grass
$3.75 / bale
Ashville, NY
View Listing
Black and brown cows eating fresh hay from a feeder in a New York pasture at sunset.

Organic Timothy/Alfalfa Round Bales

Timothy/Alfalfa Mix (organic)
$40 / bale
La Fargeville, NY
View Listing
A group of cows eating fresh hay on a farm in New York

Wrapped Baleage – Timothy/Alfalfa

Timothy/Alfalfa Baleage (organic)
$40 / bale
La Fargeville, NY
View Listing
A group of black and brown cows eating the best hay on a farm in New York state during sunset.

1st Cutting Timothy Grass – Small Squares

Timothy Grass · First Cutting
$7 / bale
Goshen, NY
View Listing
Black and brown cows eating fresh hay from a feeder in a New York pasture at sunset.

1st Cutting Organic Timothy

Timothy Grass (organic) · First Cutting
$7 / bale
Goshen, NY
View Listing
A group of cows eating fresh hay on a farm in New York

2nd Cutting Timothy

Timothy Grass · Second Cutting
$9 / bale
Goshen, NY
View Listing
Two miniature horses eating hay from a metal feeder at a farm in New York

Horse-Quality 1st Cut – Small Squares

Orchard/Timothy/Alfalfa Mix · First Cutting
$4.40 / bale
Prattsburgh, NY
View Listing
Cows grazing on hay in a New York pasture at sunset

Timothy/Alfalfa Mix – Small Squares

Timothy/Alfalfa Mix · Mixed
Contact for price
Camillus, NY
View Listing
A person offering a bale of fresh green hay to two mini horses on a farm in New York.

Premium Tested Horse Hay – Small Squares

Timothy/Orchard/Clover
$6 / bale
Hobart, NY
View Listing
Cows grazing on hay in a New York pasture at sunset

Large Square Bales – Native Grass Hay

Orchard/Timothy/Clover
Contact for price
Hobart, NY
View Listing
Black and brown cows eating fresh hay from a feeder in a New York pasture at sunset.

First Cutting Timothy Grass Hay — Square Bales

Timothy / Grass Mix · First Cutting
$6 / bale
Salem, NY
View Listing
New Timothy Hay listings are added regularly. Growers can list hay for free, and buyers can post a Hay Wanted request to let local sellers reach out.

Selling Timothy Hay?

List your hay for free and connect with buyers across New York looking for Timothy Hay. No broker fees, no listing costs.
List Your Hay Free

Browse Other Hay Types

Timothy Hay  ·  Alfalfa Hay  ·  Orchard Grass  ·  Mixed Grass  ·  First Cutting  ·  Second Cutting  ·  Straw  ·  Horse Hay

Browse Hay by New York Region

Western New York  ·  Finger Lakes  ·  Southern Tier  ·  Central New York  ·  Mohawk Valley  ·  North Country  ·  Capital Region  ·  Hudson Valley  ·  Long Island