Hay for Sale Across Finger Lakes, New York

The Finger Lakes region — Ontario, Livingston, Wayne, Seneca, Yates and their neighbors — is some of New York’s best farmland, known for quality grass, timothy and alfalfa hay alongside its famous vineyards. Find hay for sale from Finger Lakes farms below, or list your own hay free to reach local horse and livestock owners.

Available Hay Listings in Finger Lakes

Black and brown cows eating fresh hay from a feeder in a New York pasture at sunset.

Organic 2nd Cut Alfalfa – Large Rounds

Alfalfa (organic) · Second Cutting
$50 / bale
Penn Yan, NY
View Listing
A group of cows eating fresh hay on a farm in New York

Organic Grass Hay – Large Squares

Grass Hay (organic)
$50 / bale
Penn Yan, NY
View Listing
A group of black and brown cows eating the best hay on a farm in New York state during sunset.

Hay for Sale – Western NY

Grass Hay
Contact for price
Java, NY
View Listing
Cows grazing on hay in a New York pasture at sunset

Hay Auction – Fridays

Grass Hay (auction)
Contact for price
Penn Yan, NY
View Listing
Black and brown cows eating fresh hay from a feeder in a New York pasture at sunset.

Hay & Straw Auction – Wednesdays

Grass Hay & Straw (auction)
Contact for price
Canandaigua, NY
View Listing
Cattle feeding on high-quality hay in a New York pasture at golden hour.

Hay Auction – Fridays

Grass Hay (auction)
Contact for price
Stanley, NY
View Listing
A group of black and brown cows eating the best hay on a farm in New York state during sunset.

High-Quality Hay – Self-Serve 24/7

Grass Hay
Contact for price
Pittsford, NY
View Listing
New hay listings across Finger Lakes are added regularly. Growers can list hay for free, and buyers can post a Hay Wanted request to let local sellers reach out.

Sell Your Hay in Finger Lakes

List your hay for free and connect with local buyers across New York. No broker fees, no listing costs — just simple, local sales.
List Your Hay Free

Browse Hay by Type

Other New York Regions